基于生命周期评价法的黄磷产品碳足迹分析

doi:10.19964/j.issn.1006-4990.2023-0222

Abstract

Abstract:

Yellow phosphorus，as a high energy consumption and high carbon emission product，to find out its carbon emission footprint and promote its low carbon development is of great significance to our “double carbon” strategy.Taking a 50 000 t/a yellow phosphorus enterprise in Guizhou province as an example，Life Cycle Assessment（LCA） was adopted to quantitatively analyze the carbon footprint of yellow phosphorus products in the production process，and proposed corresponding energy-saving and carbon reduction measures for its green and low-carbon development.The research results showed that the carbon footprint of each ton of yellow phosphorus in the production process was 1.580×10⁴ kg CO₂.The carbon emissions were concentrated in the two aspects of tail gas treatment and power consumption，which was accounted for 90.08% of the total.Based on its carbon footprint accounting results，it was proposed to adopt green power production，rational use of the geographical advantages of phosphorus resources，strengthen process control，and comprehensive utilization of yellow phosphorus tail gas and other emission reduction measures to reduce the carbon footprint of yellow phosphorus production process.

Key words: “dual carbon” strategy, life cycle assessment, yellow phosphorus, carbon footprint, energy conservation and carbon reduction

CLC Number:

TQ127.1

WANG Xuemeng, AN Yan, LIU Hai, TIAN Mengkui. Carbon footprint analysis of yellow phosphorus products based on LCA[J]. Inorganic Chemicals Industry, 2023, 55(12): 36-42.

Figures/Tables 11

Fig.1

Fig.2

Fig.3

Table 1

Carbon footprint calculation method of yellowphosphorus production process"

统计类别	碳足迹核算
原材料消耗	$E 原材料$ =AD_原材料×EF_原材料
生产过程	$E 过程$ 尾气监测数据
净购入电力	$E 电$ =AD_电×EF_电
净购入热力	$E 热$ =AD_热×EF_热
原材料运输	$E 运输$ =AD_运输×EF_运输
尾气处理	$E 尾气$ 根据尾气监测数据计算
磷渣处理	$E 炉渣$ 根据炉渣电力、热力消耗数据计算
总计	$E 总 = E 原材料 + E 过程 + E 电 + E 热 + E 运输 + E 尾气 + E 炉渣$

Table 1

Table 2

Table 3

Table 4

Table 5

Table 6

Fig.4

Fig.5

References 32

1	王莹，熊先孝，东野脉兴，等. 中国磷矿资源预测模型及找矿远景分析［J］. 中国地质， 2022， 49（2）：435-454.
	WANG Ying， XIONG Xianxiao， DONGYE Maixing， et al. Prediction model and exploration prospect analysis of phosphate mineral resources in China［J］. Geology in China， 2022， 49（2）：435-454.
2	国家发展改革委，工业和信息化部，生态环境部，等. 高耗能行业重点领域节能降碳改造升级实施指南（2022年版）［R/OL］.（ 2022-02-15）［ 2023-04-17］.https：//www.ndrc.gov.cn/xwdt/ztzl/ghnhyjnjdgzsj/zcwj/202202/t20220217_1315689_ext.html.
3	孙铭蔚，狄飞，李晶莹，等. 面向产品制造过程的碳效率评价方法研究［J］. 机电产品开发与创新， 2022， 35（3）：84-87.
	SUN Mingwei， DI Fei， LI Jingying， et al. Research on carbon efficiency evaluation method for product manufacturing process［J］. Development & Innovation of Machinery & Electrical Products， 2022， 35（3）：84-87.
4	李洪丞，曹华军，刘兰微，等. 碳达峰碳中和背景下低碳制造研究现状与技术路径研究［J/OL］. 机械工程学报， 2023：1-16.［ 2023-02-24］.https：//kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/11.2187.TH.20230223.0907.044.html.
	LI Hongcheng， CAO Huajun， LIU Lanwei， et al. Research status and technology path of low-carbon manufacturing under the background of emission peak and carbon neutrality［J/OL］. Journal of Mechanical Engineering， 2023：1-16.［ 2023-02-24］. https：//kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/11.2187.TH.20230223.0907.044.html.
5	董书恒，逯承鹏，唐呈瑞，等. 基于生命周期的原镁生产过程碳足迹分析［J］. 辽宁大学学报（自然科学版）， 2020， 47（1）：34-41.
	DONG Shuheng， LU Chengpeng， TANG Chengrui， et al. The carbon footprint in the production process of raw magnesium in China［J］. Journal of Liaoning University（Natural Sciences Edition）， 2020， 47（1）：34-41.
6	WANG Qiang， GE Shuting. Carbon footprint and water footprint in China：Similarities and differences［J］. Science of the Total Environment， 2020， 739：140070. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.140070
7	WIEDMANN T， MINX J C. A definition of carbon footprint［J］. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine， 2009， 92（4）：193-195. doi: 10.1177/014107689909200410
8	王俊博，李鑫，田继军，等. 煤炭开发利用产业碳足迹计算方法及减排措施综述［J/OL］. 煤炭学报， 2022：1-13.［ 2022-05-17］.https：//kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/11.2190.TD.20220516.1853.002.html.
	WANG Junbo， LI Xin， TIAN Jijun， et al. Summary of carbon footprint calculation methods and emission reduction measures for coal exploitation and utilization industry［J/OL］. Journal of China Coal Society， 2022：1-13.［ 2022-05-17］. https：//kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/11.2190.TD.20220516.1853.002.html.
9	WANG Haiying， WANG Yue， MI Hong， et al. Analysis of carbon emission energy inventory from refrigerant production and recycling carbon compensation［J］. Applied Sciences， 2021， 12（1）. Doi：10.3390/app12010001 .
10	CHEN Wei， ZHANG Qian， WANG Chengxin， et al. Environmental sustainability challenges of China’s steel production：Impact-oriented water，carbon and fossil energy footprints assessment［J］. Ecological Indicators， 2022， 136：108660. doi: 10.1016/j.ecolind.2022.108660
11	孙群，张为民. 基于碳足迹的生产过程分级递阶控制技术研究［J］. 中国机械工程， 2011， 22（9）：1035-1038，1111.
	SUN Qun， ZHANG Weimin. Carbon footprint based multilevel hierarchical production process control［J］. China Mechanical Engineering， 2011， 22（9）：1035-1038，1111.
12	陈广卫，张志智. 对二甲苯产品的碳足迹与减排措施［J］. 化工环保， 2021， 41（6）：774-778. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1006-1878.2021.06.019
	CHEN Guangwei， ZHANG Zhizhi. Carbon footprint and emission reduction measures of p-xylene products［J］. Environmental Protection of Chemical Industry， 2021， 41（6）：774-778. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1006-1878.2021.06.019
13	张旭辉，郭欢欢，马宏伟，等. 基于生命周期的采煤机绿色评价方法研究及应用［J］. 煤炭科学技术， 2021， 49（6）：205-212.
	ZHANG Xuhui， GUO Huanhuan， MA Hongwei， et al. Research and application of green evaluation method for shearer based on life cycle［J］. Coal Science and Technology， 2021， 49（6）：205- 212.
14	ZHOU Xinying， ZHAI Yijie， REN Ke， et al. Life cycle assessment of polycarbonate production：Proposed optimization toward sustainability［J］. Resources，Conservation and Recycling， 2023， 189：106765.
15	来鑫，陈权威，顾黄辉，等. 面向“双碳”战略目标的锂离子电池生命周期评价：框架、方法与进展［J］. 机械工程学报， 2022， 58（22）：3-18. doi: 10.3901/JME.2022.22.003
	LAI Xin， CHEN Quanwei， GU Huanghui， et al. Life cycle assessment of lithium-ion batteries for carbon-peaking and carbon-neutrality：Framework，methods，and progress［J］. Journal of Mechanical Engineering， 2022， 58（22）：3-18. doi: 10.3901/JME.2022.22.003
16	ZHAO Yingxin， YANG Zhifan， NIU Jiaojiao， et al. Systematical analysis of sludge treatment and disposal technologies for carbon footprint reduction［J］. Journal of Environmental Sciences， 2023， 128：224-249. doi: 10.1016/j.jes.2022.07.038 pmid: 36801037
17	谢明辉，满贺诚，段华波，等. 生命周期影响评价方法及本地化研究进展［J］. 环境工程技术学报， 2022， 12（6）：2148-2156.
	XIE Minghui， MAN Hecheng， DUAN Huabo， et al. Research progress on the life cycle impact assessment methods and their localization in China［J］. Journal of Environmental Engineering Technology， 2022， 12（6）：2148-2156.
18	姜兴宇，刘傲，杨国哲，等. 激光增材制造过程低碳建模与工艺参数优化［J］. 机械工程学报， 2022， 58（5）：223-238. doi: 10.3901/JME.2022.05.223
	JIANG Xingyu， LIU Ao， YANG Guozhe， et al. Low-carbon modeling and process parameter optimization in laser additive manufacturing process［J］. Journal of Mechanical Engineering， 2022， 58（5）：223-238. doi: 10.3901/JME.2022.05.223
19	王辛龙，许德华，钟艳君，等. 中国磷化工行业60年发展历程及未来发展趋势［J］. 无机盐工业， 2020， 52（10）：9-17.
	WANG Xinlong， XU Dehua， ZHONG Yanjun， et al. Future trend and development course of phosphorus chemical industry for sixty years in China［J］. Inorganic Chemicals Industry， 2020， 52（10）：9-17.
20	孟昊，陆思伟. 电炉法生产黄磷安全风险分析与防范［J］. 无机盐工业， 2014， 46（6）：56-58.
	MENG Hao， LU Siwei. Safety risks analysis and precautions for yellow phosphorus production with electric furnace process［J］. Inorganic Chemicals Industry， 2014， 46（6）：56-58.
21	GUI Fangzhi， REN Shedong， ZHAO Yanwei， et al. Activity-based allocation and optimization for carbon footprint and cost in product lifecycle［J］. Journal of Cleaner Production， 2019， 236：117627. doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.117627
22	英国标准协会. PAS 2050：2008 商品和服务在生命周期内的温室气体排放评价规范［S］. 2008.
23	马越峰，张铭，李建忠. 烧结钕铁硼磁性材料碳足迹核算分析［J］. 稀土， 2021， 42（1）：72-80.
	MA Yuefeng， ZHANG Ming， LI Jianzhong. Assessment of the carbon footprint of sintered PrNdFeB magnetic material based on life cycle assessment［J］. Chinese Rare Earths， 2021， 42（1）：72-80.
24	孙志立. 黄磷生产的节能途径与措施［J］. 化肥工业， 2015， 42（5）：10-12，83.
	SUN Zhili. Ways and measures of energy saving in yellow phosphorus production［J］. Chemical Fertilizer Industry， 2015， 42（5）：10-12，83.
25	顾志勤. 黄磷生产中的能耗和节能措施综述（Ⅰ）［J］. 硫磷设计与粉体工程， 2006（1）：20-27.
	GU Zhiqin. Overview of energy consumption and energy-saving measures in yellow phosphorus production（Ⅰ）［J］. Sulphur Phosphorus & Bulk Materials Handling Related Engineering， 2006（1）：20-27.
26	李枫. 黄磷生产的节能途径与措施［J］. 云南化工， 2018， 45（3）：187-188.
	LI Feng. Energy-saving ways and measures of yellow phosphorus production［J］. Yunnan Chemical Technology， 2018， 45（3）：187- 188.
27	孙志立. 制磷电炉内电流、热量分布对制磷电炉运行的影响分析［J］. 磷肥与复肥， 2009， 24（5）：50-54.
	SUN Zhili. Study on the distributions of electric current and heat in phosphorus furnace and its effect on the operation of the furnace［J］. Phosphate & Compound Fertilizer， 2009， 24（5）：50-54.
28	孙志立. 黄磷生产炭质还原剂的选用［J］. 武汉工程大学学报， 2013， 35（9）：69-75.
	SUN Zhili. On selection of carbonaceous reductant in yellow phosphorus production［J］. Journal of Wuhan Institute of Technology， 2013， 35（9）：69-75.
29	陈善继. 磷矿组分对黄磷产品电炉能耗的影响［J］. 硫磷设计与粉体工程， 2002（2）：13-17.
	CHEN Shanji. The influence of the composition of the phosphate rock on the energy consumption of the electric furnace for phosphorus production［J］. Sulphur Phosphorus & Bulk Materials Handling Related Engineering， 2002（2）：13-17.
30	梁志飞，贾旭东. 绿电交易关键问题及政策建议［J］. 中国电力企业管理， 2022（10）：26-29.
	LIANG Zhifei， JIA Xudong. Key problems and policy suggestions of green electricity trading［J］. China Power Enterprise Management， 2022（10）：26-29.
31	牟晨璐，丁涛，周郑洋，等. 面向碳中和的工业尾气电厂技术综述及其典型案例经济性分析［J］. 电力自动化设备， 2021， 41（9）：74-84.
	MU Chenlu， DING Tao， ZHOU Zhengyang， et al. Technology review on industrial off-gas power plants for carbon neutral and economic analysis of typical cases［J］. Electric Power Automation Equipment， 2021， 41（9）：74-84.
32	彭元洪，万源，刘新坤，等. 黄磷尾气蒸汽锅炉新技术［J］. 无机盐工业， 2010， 42（8）：39-40.
	PENG Yuanhong， WAN Yuan， LIU Xinkun， et al. New steam boiler technology for utilization of yellow phosphorus tail gas［J］. Inorganic Chemicals Industry， 2010， 42（8）：39-40.

物料名称	碳排放因子	数据来源
磷矿石	0.013 34 kg/kg	CLCD中国生命周期基础数据库
焦炭	0.133 65 kg/kg	CLCD中国生命周期基础数据库
硅石	0.039 30 kg/kg	CLCD中国生命周期基础数据库
运输	0.177 20 kg/（t·km）	ECLC3.0&Encoinvent
电力（南方区域）	0.508 85 kg/（kW·h）	省级温室气体清单编制指南
热力	0.110 00 kg/MJ	CLCD中国生命周期基础数据库

项目	CO₂的排放量/kg	项目	CO₂的排放量/kg
磷矿石	1.293×10²	热力	2.464×10²
焦炭	2.459×10²	过程排放	2.165×10²
硅石	76.64	尾气处理	7.592×10³
运输	37.55	磷渣处理	6.178×10²
电力	6.642×10³	总计	1.580×10⁴

[1]	CHEN Tao, GAO Huimin. Study on preparation of phosphorus trichloride by microreaction [J]. Inorganic Chemicals Industry, 2023, 55(4): 72-75.
[2]	HE Haodong,YANG Lin,CAO Jianxin. Preparation of high temperature composite phase change energy storage materials by yellow phosphorus slag and Na₂SO₄-NaCl [J]. Inorganic Chemicals Industry, 2023, 55(2): 126-131.
[3]	ZHOU Shiyu,HE Ting,FU Tongtong,GUO Zirui,GU Shuai,YU Jianguo. Life cycle and economic assessment of recycling spent lithium-ion batteries with hydrometallurgical process [J]. Inorganic Chemicals Industry, 2023, 55(1): 26-32.
[4]	WANG Jie,GU Shouyu,HOU Cuihong,HOU Lishuang,LIU Yuqiong,WANG Menglai,DU Xiongyan,JIANG Wei,LIU Zufeng. Preparation of rice special fertilizer in Yunnan，Guizhou，Sichuan area by modification of yellow phosphorus residue [J]. Inorganic Chemicals Industry, 2022, 54(12): 79-86.
[5]	JIANG Xiang-Fei, LI Jun, LIU Xue-Feng, LUO Jian-Hong, JIN Yang, YAO Wei-Dong. Study on purification of yellow phosphorus by nitric acid oxidation combined with zone melting [J]. INORGANICCHEMICALSINDUSTRY, 2014, 46(3): 32-.
[6]	LI Xian-Rong, CHEN Ning, DONG Ming-Fu, XIE You-Cai, HUANG Yu-Xi, YUAN Xiao-Chao. Detoxification of chromium residue by yellow phosphorus tail gas [J]. INORGANICCHEMICALSINDUSTRY, 2014, 46(12): 54-.
[7]	HU Xue-Qiong, NING Ping, GAO Hua-Ping, GAN Ping-Xiang, SONG Zhong-Xian. Yellow phosphorus tail gas as alternative fuel for lime kiln calcining process [J]. INORGANICCHEMICALSINDUSTRY, 2013, 45(12): 38-.
[8]	KANG Xin-Ying, SU Yi, CHA Zuo-Tong. Study on separating characteristics of iron and calcium in the acid leaching process of yellow phosphorus slag [J]. INORGANICCHEMICALSINDUSTRY, 2012, 44(8): 43-.
[9]	TANG Jian-Wei, ZHANG Yang-Yang, HUA Quan-Xian, LIU Yong, JIANG Zhen-Xi, LIU Li, HE Feng-Bin. Development of decision support system for technological assessment of phosphorus chemical industry [J]. INORGANICCHEMICALSINDUSTRY, 2012, 44(4): 46-.
[10]	HUANG Qian-Jun. Progresses in research and production of electronic grade phosphoric acid [J]. INORGANICCHEMICALSINDUSTRY, 2012, 44(2): 1-.
[11]	TAO Jun-Fa-1, YANG Jian-Zhong-2. Present status and developmental direction of phosphorus chemical industry in China [J]. INORGANICCHEMICALSINDUSTRY, 2011, 43(1): 1-3.
[12]	Pen Yuanhong;Wan Yuan;Liu Xinkun;Tang Yunzhong;Zhang Chaokun. New steam boiler technology for utilization of yellow phosphorus tail gas [J]. INORGANICCHEMICALSINDUSTRY, 2010, 0(8): 0-0.
[13]	Tang Liping;He Dengliang;Huang Lili;Luo Yaju;Zhang Baoshu. Preparation of white carbon black with phosphoric acid from yellow phosphorus slag [J]. INORGANICCHEMICALSINDUSTRY, 2010, 0(7): 0-0.
[14]	Zha Zuotong;Ma Yanli;Li Guobin;Su Yi. Experimental study on oxidizing phosphorous acid in waste liquid of refining yellow phosphorus [J]. INORGANICCHEMICALSINDUSTRY, 2010, 0(7): 0-0.
[15]	Liu Jun;Li Jun;Ren Yongsheng;Liu Minha. Effect of oxidation reinforcer on removing arsenic from yellow phosphorus [J]. INORGANICCHEMICALSINDUSTRY, 2010, 0(2): 0-0.

National Inorganic Salts Information Center

Inorganic Acid-Base-Salt Committee of CIESC

Carbon footprint analysis of yellow phosphorus products based on LCA

RichHTML

PDF (PC)

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

Figures/Tables 11

References 32

Related Articles 15

Metrics

Comments

Recommended 0